Alderperson District 4· 2025-04-15–2027-04-01 (start 2025-04-15 per Council Organizational Meeting Minutes oath; month-level end: April 2027 - two-year term, successors sworn at the April organizational meeting)
Cathy Stoodley
Lake Geneva
No biography on file yet.
Voice
- Meetings spoken in
- 47
- Total speaking time
- 4:45:22
- Avg per meeting
- 6:04
- Segments
- 5034
Want every word Stoodley has said?
The OpenCity MCP for Claude.ai answers questions like “what has Stoodley said about housing this year” with one prompt — full speaking history, with YouTube timestamps.
Top issues during term (20)
2027 Budgets and Capital Improvement Planning
The city budget being crafted now will determine spending and tax levels for the coming year.
Future Public Safety Facility and Edwards Boulevard Land Purchase
The site evaluation itself costs staff time, but the eventual fire/police facility would be a major capital expense on whatever site is chosen.
Changing City Attorney from elected to appointed position
Cost of an elected versus appointed attorney is unknown — alders said a cost comparison is needed before any referendum.
Highway 50 construction update
State disaster reimbursement of roughly 70% for July 3 storm damage is being documented; storm costs will exceed the $104,000 preliminary estimate.
Highway 50 project
State disaster reimbursement of roughly 70% for July 3 storm damage is being documented; storm costs will exceed the $104,000 preliminary estimate.
YMCA Funding Dispute and Process Breakdown
None directly — the failed motion would only have authorized feasibility discussions with a report due by November 30.
Hillmoor property future use
Roughly $300,000 is expected over the first three years of restoration work, with costs dropping after that.
Child Safety Zones Ordinance Update
Peller Property Land Use Map Amendment
The attorney for the Pellers says the town currently collects only about $4,000 a year in property taxes on the land, so any tax shift would be minimal.
Cemetery Stewardship Fund creation
Revenue increases intended to make the cemetery self-sustaining; current rates are far below regional comparables.
Public Works Mechanic Position
The mechanic position is unbudgeted for 2027; funding decisions would come in the 2028 budget cycle.
Symphony Bay path surface and erosion concerns
Gravel is cheaper to maintain than mulch, and the no-plowing condition avoids winter plowing costs, though Fesenmaier seeks a dedicated maintenance line item.
Broad Street and Highway 120 construction
State disaster reimbursement of roughly 70% for July 3 storm damage is being documented; storm costs will exceed the $104,000 preliminary estimate.
2026 Lead Service Line Replacement Project
Cost not yet specified until bids come in next year.
Otty's and Mashtun Brewing building at 140 Broad St
Adds a commercial business to the downtown tax base.
Preliminary 2026 Sidewalk Assessments
Assessments range from $15.40 to over $5,000 per parcel, payable over ten years for larger amounts.
Storm Damage and Veterans Park Playground
The capital improvement plan included roughly $1.2 million toward a multipurpose building at the park.
Future lakefront Capital Improvement Projects
Permanent docks could save roughly $100,000 a year in seasonal install/removal costs; a new pier would be expensive but potentially donor-funded.
Fence CUP Denial at 533 Spring Street
Alder agenda item request process
No direct cost — this is about procedure, though opponents say slower routing wastes meeting time.
Decisions during term (436)
Recorded while Stoodley was in office — not necessarily decisions they moved, spoke to, or voted on.
Add $75,000 Veterans Park playground edging to capital plan
Consent Agenda (items 10.a–10.f)
Ordinance 26-11 — Televised meetings for Personnel and Standing Committees
Charter Ordinance No. 195 — City Attorney appointment amendment
Resolution 26-R59 — Publish 2027 budget public hearing notice
Surplus auction items list — Department of Public Works
Hydrant relocation and new hydrant installation (PIN ZYUP00131)
Joint public hearing date for Peller Investments land use map amendment
Child Safety Zones — adopt Map D framework
Letter of intent — Alta Vista Foundation $5 million Hillmoor donation
Adjournment
Approval of September 21, 2026 meeting minutes
Downtown Design Review — sandwich board sign at 772 W Main Street (PC-2026-067)
Site Plan Review — mural at 600 N Edwards Boulevard (PC-2026-056)
Alley vacation in Watson's Boulevard Addition (PC-2026-073)
Conditional Use Permit for billiard parlor at 772 W Main Street (PC-2026-055)
Planned Development PIP for 140 Broad Street (PC-2026-0057)
Approve Minutes of the September 21, 2026 Plan Commission meeting as distributed.
Approval of minutes from September 21, 2026
Approval of September 2026 Financials
Voting record (143)
Oldest to newest — hover a bar for the item.
Charter Ordinance No. 195 — City Attorney appointment amendment
Preferred the mayor interview candidates and the council approve, believing council members may be swayed by individual concerns.
Resolution 26-R59 — Publish 2027 budget public hearing notice
Child Safety Zones — adopt Map D framework
Letter of intent — Alta Vista Foundation $5 million Hillmoor donation
YMCA 2027 funding set at $65,564 with offsetting Parks cuts
Add $75,000 Veterans Park playground edging to capital plan
Motion to enter closed session for Highway 50 property purchases
Resolution 26-R57: CUP for 4-foot fence at 533 Spring Street
Emphasized safety for children and pets on corner lots
Charter Ordinance: Appointed City Attorney
Urged careful, positive communication to avoid a referendum petition driven by misinformation
Public Works Mechanic Job Description
Defended public works staff and argued the basic description should be approved now
Referral of agenda item request form and ordinance change to Common Council
Motion to continue Strategic Plan Metrics
Approve Strategic Plan Metrics
Motion to go into closed session
move item 15 up
approve items a-c
continue
approve
approve
remove page 4, the snapshot page in the document
approve Resolution 26-R56
approve Resolution 26-R55
amend the resolution to add that the City will not plow the gravel path
approve
Direct the City Attorney, in consultation with the City Clerk, Administrator, and information-technology or media staff, to prepare ordinance language amending municipal code section 2-501 to require
direct the City Attorney to prepare ordinance language establishing a Finance and Operations Committee as a standing committee of the Common Council, replacing the existing Personnel Committee and ass
direct the City Attorney to prepare ordinance language establishing a nonvoting Common Council liaison to the Police and Fire Commission for purposes of communication and coordination between the Comm
Strategic Plan adoption (Item 15)
Resolution 26-R55 — Symphony Bay gravel paths
Finance and Operations Committee ordinance (Item 16)
Believes it undermines city staff credibility and prefers Committee of the Whole
Council liaison to Police and Fire Commission (Item 18)
authorize the City Administrator, Mayor and Alders Hoiland, Fesenmaier and Smith to initiate a public facilities partner initiative to include discussions with the Geneva Lakes Family YMCA and school
Resolution 26-R48 — Douglas wedding venue CUP
Opposed limiting the permit to the current owner
YMCA public facilities partnership initiative (item 17)
Neither the park board, YMCA nor consultants were consulted, and community surveys are still pending
Townline Road property for future public safety facility (item 18)
Notes the fire and police departments ruled the oddly shaped, unbuildable parcel out early
amend and make this a limited conditional use permit (to the owner)
direct the City Administrator and City Attorney to complete or coordinate a comparative due diligence evaluation of the Townline Rd. property (Tax Parcel ZSB 00331) using the same legal, engineering,
amend and add Alder Frame
Go Into Closed Session (Parks License / HWY 50 Property Purchases)
adjourn to closed session to include Police Chief Ed Gritzner, City Administrator Dave De Angelis, City Clerk Lacey L. Reynolds, City Attorney Dan Draper, Finance Director Laura Pisarcik, Assistant Ci
adjourn to closed session to include City Attorney Draper, City Administrator De Angelis and City Clerk Reynolds
Motion to go into Closed Session — Highway 50 property purchases
continue to the next council meeting on July 27, 2026
deny the second reading of Ordinance 26-08 and stay with the ordinance as is
approve Resolution 26-R32
suspend the rules for David Scotney to speak
authorize staff to solicit proposals to retain an independent municipal real estate advisor or owners representative with experience in public sector land acquisition and site selection to assist the
Resolution 26-R32 — CUP for David Scotney indoor entertainment facility
Ordinance 26-08 — Tourism Commission composition (second reading)
Purchase of 1103 S. Edwards Boulevard for police/fire facility
Concerned continued delay jeopardizes the eminent-domain timeline with the landowner.